Oswald in the doorway: the blog of the Oswald Innocence Campaign, by Ralph Cinque

tims...@gmail.com

8:08 PM (24 minutes ago)

Hi All,

Say, it looks like this "out front with Bill Shelley" red herring that
Ralph Cinque keeps trotting out actually refers to a time AFTER the
assassination:

http://www.history-matters.com/archive/jfk/wc/wr/html/WCReport_0322a.htm

You'd sure have to wonder why Cinque keeps trotting it out as something
that exonerates that blood soaked Kennedy killer, Lee Harvey Oswald.

Astounded Regards,

Tim Brennan
Sydney, Australia
*Newsgroup(s) Commentator* 

Ralph Cinque:

Brennan, did you just fall off the turnip truck? Your naivete cracks me up. That was the statement of an FBI agent. Do you think he was going to say that Oswald said he was out front with Bill Shelley during the shooting? 

No, he wasn't going to say that, Brennan. So he altered what Oswald said, converting it into him being out front with Shelley after the shooting.

So, according to Bookhout, Oswald wasn't asked his whereabouts during the shooting; nor did he volunteer it. It just never came up. During this first police interrogation, it never came up. A thousand times, we've seen and heard the first thing out of the detective's mouth, "Where were you when the crime went down?" but not this time. 

And why? Because it's the JFK assassination, which exists in its own world; its own dimension; its own universe.   

Bill Shelley left the front of the building immediately with Billy Lovelady, and they were gone before Baker even reached the steps, and that's according to both of them. And when they were finished touring the railroad tracks, they went around to the back and reentered the building through the back door. And they were inside for a long time after that- until it was time to leave for City Hall. And that means that there was NO CHANCE that Bill Shelley was out front at 3:34 when Oswald departed for home. So, what Bookhout said is not only wrong; it is totally implausible and completely impossible. 

But you see, Brennan, at the time Bookhout wrote that, he didn't know what Shelley had done, and he didn't realize that what he was claiming was an impossible thing. 

And that's how it often goes when people lie; they don't consider all the elements and ramifications that affect the credibility of the lie. They don't have enough information to lie convincingly and effectively. They think they do; but they don't. 

So no, Brennan. There is no doubt that when Oswald said he was "out with Bill Shelley in front" he meant during the motorcade and during the shooting.

Brennan: you're dumb as a brick and twice as dense.