Ralph Cinque
Here is actually what happened. Oswald was in the doorway during the motorcade. Then, he left for the lunch room. Why is uncertain, but there is reason to believe that there was some kind of commotion in the doorway. The reason I say that is because Dave Weigman did a second pass of the doorway. He filmed it as he was rounding the corner, and then after he was on Elm, he turned to his right and panned the doorway again. Something must have spurred him to do that, and I think that the most likely thing is that Bill Shelley told Oswald to go there. Recall that when Oswald gave his alibi to police, he said that he was "out with Bill Shelley in front." Why did he name Shelley? It was because Shelley was his boss, but he may also have interacted with Shelley in the doorway. This shows Oswald's route to the doorway. He went up the stairs in the southeast corner which were close to the doorway, and he walked across the second floor to get to the lunch room in the northwest corner. He was just getting there at the time Baker arrived, and we know that because Baker reported that Oswald was moving through the anteroom into the lunch room when he first saw him. So, there is no chance that Oswald was in the lunch room 90 seconds before because if he was, Baker would not have seen him in the anteroom. One can't be in two places at once, right? He could not have been in the lunch room and in the anteroom at the same time. And note that the route that I'm saying he took going up is the same route that he definitely took to go down because he walked through the office area, and that's where he encountered Mrs. Reid who reported it. So, when the shots rang out, Oswald was definitely in the doorway. He left early. And this is the route he took to get there. Oswald did not have a Coke when Baker saw him. And could he since he hadn't reached the lunch room yet? You have to get to the lunch room and be in it before you can do something in it. Right? So, Oswald did not get his Coke until after Truly and Baker left.
Here is actually what happened. Oswald was in the doorway during the motorcade. Then, he left for the lunch room. Why is uncertain, but there is reason to believe that there was some kind of commotion in the doorway. The reason I say that is because Dave Weigman did a second pass of the doorway. He filmed it as he was rounding the corner, and then after he was on Elm, he turned to his right and panned the doorway again. Something must have spurred him to do that, and I think that the most likely thing is that Bill Shelley told Oswald to go there. Recall that when Oswald gave his alibi to police, he said that he was "out with Bill Shelley in front." Why did he name Shelley? It was because Shelley was his boss, but he may also have interacted with Shelley in the doorway. This shows Oswald's route to the doorway. He went up the stairs in the southeast corner which were close to the doorway, and he walked across the second floor to get to the lunch room in the northwest corner. He was just getting there at the time Baker arrived, and we know that because Baker reported that Oswald was moving through the anteroom into the lunch room when he first saw him. So, there is no chance that Oswald was in the lunch room 90 seconds before because if he was, Baker would not have seen him in the anteroom. One can't be in two places at once, right? He could not have been in the lunch room and in the anteroom at the same time. And note that the route that I'm saying he took going up is the same route that he definitely took to go down because he walked through the office area, and that's where he encountered Mrs. Reid who reported it. So, when the shots rang out, Oswald was definitely in the doorway. He left early. And this is the route he took to get there. Oswald did not have a Coke when Baker saw him. And could he since he hadn't reached the lunch room yet? You have to get to the lunch room and be in it before you can do something in it. Right? So, Oswald did not get his Coke until after Truly and Baker left. 
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.