This is Part II of: Where Was Oswald Shot? And of course, we know it wasn't the garage. It was either in the PD or in route to the hospital. And if it's the latter, it must be connected to the stop that was made, after which Graves, in his police car, took the lead.
The gist of Part I was that if you accept Dr. Fred Bieberdorf's FBI statement, then you have to believe that Oswald was shot in the PD, since it has the Bieb saying that he saw Oswald in the jail office looking dead. But, there were problems with it, if you recall, one being that an FBI agent composed it.
So, let's look at the Bieb's WC testimony. He corrected a few minor things in his FBI statement, but none of the ones that matter to me. And then he made a false correction, which is weird. He said that Leavelle rode with him in the middle seat, but Leavlle definitely rode in back. We can see it as they are departing and as they are arriving, that Leavelle is in the back, and close to the tailgate. So, why did the Bieb say that Leavelle rode with him in the middle seat? I don't know, but it was a lie. And I do mean that it was a lie because how could he be misinformed about that? So, why'd the Bieb lie? I don't know. Maybe he was ordered to.
And you recall that the Bieb said that he concluded that Oswald was dead in the jail office. Not dying but dead. And in his WC testimony, he said he continued to think that Oswald was dead until they were close to the hospital, at which time Oswald started moving around, which told him that Oswald was alive. But, read this:
Mr. HUBERT. You were with him in the ambulance all the way through?
Dr. BIEBERDORF. Yes, sir.
Mr. HUBERT. And when he got to the ambulance you saw signs of life?
Dr. BIEBERDORF. Although, I did not until we got about halfway to Parkland.
Mr. HUBERT. You thought he was dead?
Dr. BIEBERDORF. He--I surmised he was dead until he started moving a little bit.
If the Bieb continued to think that Oswald was dead, then he wasn't "massaging Oswald's sternum" then, was he, as the FBI agent wrote? Why would a doctor, of all people, be massaging the sternum of a dead person? And likewise, if he thought Oswald was dead, he didn't put a bulb resuscitator over his mouth, on account of him being dead. So, I take the above testimony as evidence that what was stated in the FBI statement is false. But why then didn't the Bieb correct it?
The next thing is very VERY weird. Are you read for this? The Bieb said he performed a rectal examination on Jack Ruby because detectives and an FBI agent ordered him to.
Dr. BIEBERDORF. The next sentence that follows that is correct, but then there is another. That same paragraph, the last sentence in this paragraph reads, "Bieberdorf states that he gave Ruby a physical examination at this time in order to insure Ruby had not concealed any weapon on his person."
This is not correct here. Later on in the afternoon of November 24, I was asked by the police or Lieutenant--I believe in charge of the jail at that to go upstairs and at the request of detectives and one of the FBI agents, I performed a rectal examination on him to make sure he had not smuggled--or to see if he had brought anything in on his person.
This was at 6 p.m., so, I did see Ruby on two occasions. One at 2:05 and one at 6. I think that report tends to indicate it was only one.
Wait a second. Hold everything. Something is terribly wrong here. They didn't do a rectal exam on Oswald. And people get arrested all the time, for murder and other crimes, and they don't have rectal exams done on them in the police station either. So, what the mudderpluck???? Do you mean to tell me that Dallas detectives and an FBI agent actually thought that Jack Ruby might have hidden a weapon in his rectum???????????? And if not a weapon, then what? It wasn't a drug arrest. You hear about people putting a balloon with containing drugs inside themselves, and the risk is that, if it bursts, they die from a massive overdose. But, we are not talking about drugs here, are we? The implication here seems to be weapon. So, they were concerned that Jack Ruby may have shoved a gun up his butt? They were actually concerned about that? Is that what you're telling me? Because I don't believe it. Not for a second. I don't think there is any chance that they believed such a thing.
And think about something else: if you were arrested and being held at a police station, and someone ordered you to submit to a rectal exam, at the police station, are you going to do it? Are you not going to refuse? Because: you have the right to refuse. And if you do refuse, what are they going to do? Tie you down and do it anyway? I've never heard of such a thing. Have you ever heard of such a thing happening at a police station? YOU HAVE THE RIGHT TO REFUSE.
Everybody knows that people get arrested all the time for all kinds of crimes, including murder, without submitting to rectal exams at police departments. But, it sounds like Jack Ruby just went along with it. Are you starting to get the picture now about him? About how docile he was? I'm not even sure if "docile" is a strong enough word. It's beyond docile. But I'll put it this way: they ought to make that the litmus for docility: if you submit to a rectal exam at a police station without fighting it, without resisting it, without refusing, you are the most docile mudderpluck to ever walk the face of the Earth. It doesn't get any more docile than that.
But, why did they do it? They could not have thought he had a gun up his butt. Are you kidding? They knew very well that Jack Ruby didn't shoot Oswald. So, why would he have a gun up his butt?
All I can gather is that this was about psychologically battering Jack Ruby, destroying his sense of self, humiliating him, and also testing him to see how compliant he was. Was there anything he wouldn't do? Apparently not.
But consider something else: you may be aware that I maintain that Ruby was drugged to get him to the police station, and the drug they gave him was scopolamine, which makes you compliant. It makes you do whatever you are told- no matter what. So, was that a factor in Ruby's willingness to cooperate with this outrageous demand?
And what about Bieberdorf? Was he used to doing rectal exams on prisoners at the police department? I don't get his cooperation about this either. It seems like he would have said, "What for?" And they weren't going to say "drugs" because drugs were not formally an issue that day. And if they said guns, he could have informed them that putting a pistol up his butt was not anything that Jack Ruby could have done, to just consider it to be physically impossible. He could have told them that. So, detectives and an FBI agent tell him to perform a rectal exam on a prisoner, and he just says, "OK" and does it? It's crazy!
By the way, he said Ruby described the procedure as "the worst massage he ever got in his life."
I admit that I have a very bad impression of Dr. Fred Bieberdorf, both as a doctor and as a man, and it affects my opinion about where Oswald was shot. And I will render my opinion about where he was shot, but not tonight. Part III comes tomorrow.
Monday, January 8, 2018
Sunday, January 7, 2018
Some people were surprised when they read that I am sure James Bookhout didn't shoot Oswald. They thought I was reversing myself. Not true. James Bookhout was definitely the Garage Shooter. But, it was a ruse. Oswald was not shot in the garage. It was all an act for television.
I really have no doubt about that. There is no sign of any blood or trauma to Oswald. And look at the Jackson photo, with limbs akimbo, all to hide the area of impact- because there was no impact. And look at how Oswald was extracted from the garage lightening-fast, and without a glimpse of it being caught on camera. And that makes no sense. How do you hide a object consisting of two men carrying a third man? It's God-damn big, you know? And, they reportedly got Oswald inside before they got the shooter inside, but how when he was so gravely injured? Why would they hastiliy do that? They really had no reason to move him at all. But, they certainly would not move an abdominal gunshot victim hastily. Wouldn't they first appraise his condition? Figure out, first, if he's alive, and if so, how badly he's hurt? And then, wouldn't they figure out how to move him delicately, gingerly, with the least amount of jostling? He was, after all, an abdominal gunshot victim. Yet, we didn't get a glimpse or a glimmer of it.
Another factor is that Oswald did too much after being shot. The damage was instant; his major blood vessels severed and his circulation in complete collapse. So, how could he go up on his toes after incurring such catastrophic trauma? I have got his feet circled. He is up on his toes.
Upon being shot, Oswald cringed and started collapsing forward. But then, he veered backward and went up on his toes. But how? He couldn't have done it if he had been hit. He would have just gone down.
Then, the fact is that the course of the bullet was downward in Oswald's body. It entered at the 7th left rib and halted at the 11th right rib. That's a downward trajectory. But, the short Garage Shooter appeared to be shooting upward into Oswald.
He certainly didn't shoot downward. So, he could not have made the shot that devastated Oswald.
So, was Oswald shot in the PD or on the way to the hospital? We are going to explore that. And the answer depends on what you think of Dr. Fred Bieberdorf. If you take what he said at face value, then you have to believe that Oswald was shot in the PD. Because, after all, the Bieb claimed to see Oswald near dead in the jail office. In fact, he thought he was dead. However, I should point out that I am referring to the Bieb's FBI statement not his WC testimony. And, the Bieb didn't write his FBI statement. Like Carolyn Arnold and Marrion Baker and many others, his words were parsed by an FBI agent who took his story. But, the Bieb did get a chance to edit it the statement in front of the Warren Commission, and the only thing he corrected was the description of where Oswald was struck. In the FBI report, it said "below the ribcage" and at his WC testimony, the Bieb acknowledged that the bullet went through the rib cage. He estimated it was the 5th or 6th rib, though it was actually the 7th. This is from his FBI statement:
If you accept the Bieb's above statement as accurate, then obviously, Oswald was already shot when he saw him. But, there are problems with the statement. If he couldn't detect a pulse, heartbeat, or respiration, then obviously Oswald was dead. But, we know that isn't the truth. Oswald reached the hospital alive. Barely alive, but alive. So, that means that he must have had a heartbeat and pulse and respiration. The FBI agent mentioned the noise in the jail office, but that only affects hearing, not palpation. Shouldn't the Bieb still have detected a pulse? And, by necessity, Oswald must have been breathing. So, the Bieb wasn't a very good doctor if he couldn't detect it. It's not just about hearing the breathing. It's about the chest rising and falling and the ribcage expanding with each breath. So, if it was noisy, you would check for the MOVEMENT of breathing. And if the Bieb really thought that Oswald's heart had stopped beating and that he had stopped breathing, why didn't he begin cardiopulmonary resuscitation? The FBI mentioned sternal massage, but that wouldn't have done any good. I am talking about chest compressions and mouth-to-mouth. And don't tell me the Bieb did either one in there because if he had, we'd have heard about it from multiple witnesses, including the Bieb himself. He never claimed to do it. So, a doctor finds a moribund victim who isn't breathing or circulating, and he doesn't try to resuscitate him?
The FBI agent said that the Bieb continued his "sternal massage" on the way to the hospital and that he used an oxygen cup resuscitator on Oswald, but there are no reports of that from anyone, including Bieberdorf. And where did the oxygen cup resuscitator come from? You can't tell me the Bieb had it on him. Doctors don't walk around with those things. And I don't accept that it was in the ambulance. The ambulance was just a station wagon, and the attendants were just the driver and his assistant- to assist him in loading the victim into it. They didn't do ANYTHING medical. They weren't trained to do anything medical. They were just transporters. Neither Hardin, nor Leavelle, no Dhority said anything about the Bieb using an oxygen cup resuscitator on Oswald, and the Bieb never claimed it either.
So, there are problems, huge problems, with the Bieb's FBI statement. If you accept it at face value, then obviously, Oswald was already shot. But, I certainly don't accept it at face value. And, if the entrance wound was clean and bloodless, as the Bieb claimed, then how did all this blood get on the floor beneath Oswald?
And finally, I'll point out that if Oswald looked as bad as the Bieb claimed to find him in the jail office, then how he doesn't look so bad when we see him in the garage subsequent to that?
Notice that Oswald's right hand looks extremely pale, but not his left hand, nor his face. And how did his right arm get to where we see it? The Bieb said that somebody had lifted up Oswald's clothes exposing the wound. So, his clothes were restored, and then they placed his right arm over his torso? Why would they do that? You're not supposed to put any weight on top of an abdomen with a gunshot wound because the pressure of the weight is likely to increase the bleeding. And, you can't claim that Oswald did that because he was unconscious.
So, there are problems with the Bieb's statement, and there are problems with this image. And that's why I leave open the possibility that it's all a lie, and Oswald wasn't shot yet at all. However, I don't doubt that he was unconscious. I presume that when Oswald was hustled into the jail office, the first thing they did was knock him out, perhaps with a hypodermic needle. This is Part 1. Part II to follow.
I really have no doubt about that. There is no sign of any blood or trauma to Oswald. And look at the Jackson photo, with limbs akimbo, all to hide the area of impact- because there was no impact. And look at how Oswald was extracted from the garage lightening-fast, and without a glimpse of it being caught on camera. And that makes no sense. How do you hide a object consisting of two men carrying a third man? It's God-damn big, you know? And, they reportedly got Oswald inside before they got the shooter inside, but how when he was so gravely injured? Why would they hastiliy do that? They really had no reason to move him at all. But, they certainly would not move an abdominal gunshot victim hastily. Wouldn't they first appraise his condition? Figure out, first, if he's alive, and if so, how badly he's hurt? And then, wouldn't they figure out how to move him delicately, gingerly, with the least amount of jostling? He was, after all, an abdominal gunshot victim. Yet, we didn't get a glimpse or a glimmer of it.
Another factor is that Oswald did too much after being shot. The damage was instant; his major blood vessels severed and his circulation in complete collapse. So, how could he go up on his toes after incurring such catastrophic trauma? I have got his feet circled. He is up on his toes.
Upon being shot, Oswald cringed and started collapsing forward. But then, he veered backward and went up on his toes. But how? He couldn't have done it if he had been hit. He would have just gone down.
Then, the fact is that the course of the bullet was downward in Oswald's body. It entered at the 7th left rib and halted at the 11th right rib. That's a downward trajectory. But, the short Garage Shooter appeared to be shooting upward into Oswald.
He certainly didn't shoot downward. So, he could not have made the shot that devastated Oswald.
So, was Oswald shot in the PD or on the way to the hospital? We are going to explore that. And the answer depends on what you think of Dr. Fred Bieberdorf. If you take what he said at face value, then you have to believe that Oswald was shot in the PD. Because, after all, the Bieb claimed to see Oswald near dead in the jail office. In fact, he thought he was dead. However, I should point out that I am referring to the Bieb's FBI statement not his WC testimony. And, the Bieb didn't write his FBI statement. Like Carolyn Arnold and Marrion Baker and many others, his words were parsed by an FBI agent who took his story. But, the Bieb did get a chance to edit it the statement in front of the Warren Commission, and the only thing he corrected was the description of where Oswald was struck. In the FBI report, it said "below the ribcage" and at his WC testimony, the Bieb acknowledged that the bullet went through the rib cage. He estimated it was the 5th or 6th rib, though it was actually the 7th. This is from his FBI statement:
If you accept the Bieb's above statement as accurate, then obviously, Oswald was already shot when he saw him. But, there are problems with the statement. If he couldn't detect a pulse, heartbeat, or respiration, then obviously Oswald was dead. But, we know that isn't the truth. Oswald reached the hospital alive. Barely alive, but alive. So, that means that he must have had a heartbeat and pulse and respiration. The FBI agent mentioned the noise in the jail office, but that only affects hearing, not palpation. Shouldn't the Bieb still have detected a pulse? And, by necessity, Oswald must have been breathing. So, the Bieb wasn't a very good doctor if he couldn't detect it. It's not just about hearing the breathing. It's about the chest rising and falling and the ribcage expanding with each breath. So, if it was noisy, you would check for the MOVEMENT of breathing. And if the Bieb really thought that Oswald's heart had stopped beating and that he had stopped breathing, why didn't he begin cardiopulmonary resuscitation? The FBI mentioned sternal massage, but that wouldn't have done any good. I am talking about chest compressions and mouth-to-mouth. And don't tell me the Bieb did either one in there because if he had, we'd have heard about it from multiple witnesses, including the Bieb himself. He never claimed to do it. So, a doctor finds a moribund victim who isn't breathing or circulating, and he doesn't try to resuscitate him?
The FBI agent said that the Bieb continued his "sternal massage" on the way to the hospital and that he used an oxygen cup resuscitator on Oswald, but there are no reports of that from anyone, including Bieberdorf. And where did the oxygen cup resuscitator come from? You can't tell me the Bieb had it on him. Doctors don't walk around with those things. And I don't accept that it was in the ambulance. The ambulance was just a station wagon, and the attendants were just the driver and his assistant- to assist him in loading the victim into it. They didn't do ANYTHING medical. They weren't trained to do anything medical. They were just transporters. Neither Hardin, nor Leavelle, no Dhority said anything about the Bieb using an oxygen cup resuscitator on Oswald, and the Bieb never claimed it either.
So, there are problems, huge problems, with the Bieb's FBI statement. If you accept it at face value, then obviously, Oswald was already shot. But, I certainly don't accept it at face value. And, if the entrance wound was clean and bloodless, as the Bieb claimed, then how did all this blood get on the floor beneath Oswald?
And finally, I'll point out that if Oswald looked as bad as the Bieb claimed to find him in the jail office, then how he doesn't look so bad when we see him in the garage subsequent to that?
Notice that Oswald's right hand looks extremely pale, but not his left hand, nor his face. And how did his right arm get to where we see it? The Bieb said that somebody had lifted up Oswald's clothes exposing the wound. So, his clothes were restored, and then they placed his right arm over his torso? Why would they do that? You're not supposed to put any weight on top of an abdomen with a gunshot wound because the pressure of the weight is likely to increase the bleeding. And, you can't claim that Oswald did that because he was unconscious.
So, there are problems with the Bieb's statement, and there are problems with this image. And that's why I leave open the possibility that it's all a lie, and Oswald wasn't shot yet at all. However, I don't doubt that he was unconscious. I presume that when Oswald was hustled into the jail office, the first thing they did was knock him out, perhaps with a hypodermic needle. This is Part 1. Part II to follow.
Saturday, January 6, 2018
I've long been a fan of Vince Gill because he does it all. He composes beautiful melodies; he plays virtuoso guitar; and he sings very well too. And another thing he does very well is accompany other vocalists. He really knows how to serve the vocalist, to bring out her best, and make her shine. I think he does that better than anybody else. So, Paul Popa and I offer this tribute to Vince Gill, one of his sad country songs, a song of unrequited love, Whenever You Come Around.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MbL3SS-32Eo&feature=youtu.be
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MbL3SS-32Eo&feature=youtu.be
Those were some stone-cold bastards who killed Kennedy. They shot him right next to his wife, where she easily could have been killed. Look how they accidentally shot Connally. Don't you think that could have happened to Jackie just as easily? But, they didn't care. Oh, they would have regretted it if she was hit. After all, they were already thinking ahead to that swearing-in ceremony, where she was standing next to LBJ, like the spirit President Kennedy, looking down over the proceedings and casting his blessing and best wishes on his successor, cough-cough, hack-hack, gimme some water.
I suspect the killers looked at Kennedy's execution as a military operation against an enemy target. After all, John F. Kennedy was a traitor. He coddled Castro and humiliated the United States of America when he refused to send the Air Force into Cuba. He even paid Castro off (in baby food and supplies). He also coddled the Soviets and pursued secret negotiations with Khrushchev, in which they were to talk about total nuclear disarmament. The Constitution deems that the penalty for treason is death, and in their view, that's exactly what this was.
But, what about Oswald? What did he do? He defected to the Soviet Union? But, it was a project; their project. He didn't mean it.
I don't think there is any doubt that some of the people involved in killing Kennedy were psychopaths. Case in point: Allen Dulles. Do you have any idea how many deaths he was responsible for in the 1950s? And I don't mean just foreign leaders he didn't like, but regular people who got killed in the melee, in places like Iran, Guatamala, the Congo, and more. And note that Dulles died in a state of total, complete dementia in 1969. That was just 6 years after the JFK assassination. And since it was in January 1969, it was really more like 5 years after the JFK assassination.
Dementia comes on slowly and gradually. You can be sure he had it, to some extent, in 1963 and even more so in 1964 during the Warren Commission proceedings. And even before that, that were signs that he wasn't right in his head. Robert Kennedy told his brother that Dulles "looked like walking death" and was "going around with his head in his hands." Admiral Burke told JFK that at top level meetings, Dulles would sit there rigidly smoking his pipe and "acting like he wasn't really there." So, was part of the reason why JFK fired Dulles because he thought he was losing his mind?
Both JFK and Oswald were the fathers of young children, and no one doubts that each of them loved and adored their kids. When you kill a man with young children, you are obviously striking out at his children. What can be worse and more traumatic for a child than to lose his or her mother or father? But again, the killers didn't care. They just didn't care.
But, there is a difference between the killing of Kennedy and the killing of Oswald. With Kennedy, they did it from a distance, And as brutal and gory as it was, it was also fast. It was over within seconds. Kennedy was dead as soon as the fatal head shot hit him. He was only still alive the way a chicken is still alive for a while after it's head is cut off. What did JFK realize about what was going on? We don't know. He seemed fine as he disappeared behind the Stemons Freeway sign waving. And then when he emerged from it, he was in a panic state- and probably in a panic about breathing because the bullet in his throat was interfering with his breathing. And then after that, he seemed, in my view, to be mentally disoriented. It appears to me that his mind was affected by something. He wasn't just physically injured. He was mentally incapacitated as well. And that's why I give serious consideration to the possibility that the shot to his back was an ice bullet that carried a mind-altering agent. Did he realize before he died that what his brother Bobby warned him about, that his political enemies would seek to kill him, had come to pass. It's anybody's guess if he did.
But, with Oswald, it was different. He remained conscious and lucid throughout his 2 day ordeal. And he got to fight for himself. He was a very good advocate for himself. He defended himself well. And the 13 times in which we can hear him with our own ears and see him with our own eyes denying guilt and professing innocence, he did it very impressively and convincingly. He did damage to his killers. He landed some blows. He lost the fight, but he landed some blows. I'm reminded of the old wise crack: "I got my ass kicked when I was a kid; but nobody ever wanted to kick it twice."
I'm sure the killers were gravely disappointed when Oswald wasn't killed in the Texas Theater. And that put into place Plan B, the Jack Ruby swindle. And no, Jack Ruby did not shoot Oswald; stop with that. Enough already. Jack Ruby was just a patsy, and he was bamboozled into thinking that he shot Oswald. He had no memory of doing it. How do you think his lawyers came up with the "psychomotor epilepsy" defense? They came up with it because Jack Ruby told them that he couldn't remember anything about the shooting, just that he went to the garage, and then cops were pouncing on him, and nothing in-between. He remembered it that way because that's all that happened when he was there. But, his lawyers, addicted to Americana like most people, were unable to consider that that the Dallas Police were lying. It's not that they refused to consider it; they were mentally incapable of considering it because of their belief in America.
I don't know who shot Oswald- who actually put that bullet into him, except that I know it wasn't Jack Ruby or James Bookhout. But, it's hard for me to imagine how anyone could conjure up the will to perform such a grisly and heinous task.
I suspect the killers looked at Kennedy's execution as a military operation against an enemy target. After all, John F. Kennedy was a traitor. He coddled Castro and humiliated the United States of America when he refused to send the Air Force into Cuba. He even paid Castro off (in baby food and supplies). He also coddled the Soviets and pursued secret negotiations with Khrushchev, in which they were to talk about total nuclear disarmament. The Constitution deems that the penalty for treason is death, and in their view, that's exactly what this was.
But, what about Oswald? What did he do? He defected to the Soviet Union? But, it was a project; their project. He didn't mean it.
I don't think there is any doubt that some of the people involved in killing Kennedy were psychopaths. Case in point: Allen Dulles. Do you have any idea how many deaths he was responsible for in the 1950s? And I don't mean just foreign leaders he didn't like, but regular people who got killed in the melee, in places like Iran, Guatamala, the Congo, and more. And note that Dulles died in a state of total, complete dementia in 1969. That was just 6 years after the JFK assassination. And since it was in January 1969, it was really more like 5 years after the JFK assassination.
Dementia comes on slowly and gradually. You can be sure he had it, to some extent, in 1963 and even more so in 1964 during the Warren Commission proceedings. And even before that, that were signs that he wasn't right in his head. Robert Kennedy told his brother that Dulles "looked like walking death" and was "going around with his head in his hands." Admiral Burke told JFK that at top level meetings, Dulles would sit there rigidly smoking his pipe and "acting like he wasn't really there." So, was part of the reason why JFK fired Dulles because he thought he was losing his mind?
Both JFK and Oswald were the fathers of young children, and no one doubts that each of them loved and adored their kids. When you kill a man with young children, you are obviously striking out at his children. What can be worse and more traumatic for a child than to lose his or her mother or father? But again, the killers didn't care. They just didn't care.
But, there is a difference between the killing of Kennedy and the killing of Oswald. With Kennedy, they did it from a distance, And as brutal and gory as it was, it was also fast. It was over within seconds. Kennedy was dead as soon as the fatal head shot hit him. He was only still alive the way a chicken is still alive for a while after it's head is cut off. What did JFK realize about what was going on? We don't know. He seemed fine as he disappeared behind the Stemons Freeway sign waving. And then when he emerged from it, he was in a panic state- and probably in a panic about breathing because the bullet in his throat was interfering with his breathing. And then after that, he seemed, in my view, to be mentally disoriented. It appears to me that his mind was affected by something. He wasn't just physically injured. He was mentally incapacitated as well. And that's why I give serious consideration to the possibility that the shot to his back was an ice bullet that carried a mind-altering agent. Did he realize before he died that what his brother Bobby warned him about, that his political enemies would seek to kill him, had come to pass. It's anybody's guess if he did.
But, with Oswald, it was different. He remained conscious and lucid throughout his 2 day ordeal. And he got to fight for himself. He was a very good advocate for himself. He defended himself well. And the 13 times in which we can hear him with our own ears and see him with our own eyes denying guilt and professing innocence, he did it very impressively and convincingly. He did damage to his killers. He landed some blows. He lost the fight, but he landed some blows. I'm reminded of the old wise crack: "I got my ass kicked when I was a kid; but nobody ever wanted to kick it twice."
I'm sure the killers were gravely disappointed when Oswald wasn't killed in the Texas Theater. And that put into place Plan B, the Jack Ruby swindle. And no, Jack Ruby did not shoot Oswald; stop with that. Enough already. Jack Ruby was just a patsy, and he was bamboozled into thinking that he shot Oswald. He had no memory of doing it. How do you think his lawyers came up with the "psychomotor epilepsy" defense? They came up with it because Jack Ruby told them that he couldn't remember anything about the shooting, just that he went to the garage, and then cops were pouncing on him, and nothing in-between. He remembered it that way because that's all that happened when he was there. But, his lawyers, addicted to Americana like most people, were unable to consider that that the Dallas Police were lying. It's not that they refused to consider it; they were mentally incapable of considering it because of their belief in America.
I don't know who shot Oswald- who actually put that bullet into him, except that I know it wasn't Jack Ruby or James Bookhout. But, it's hard for me to imagine how anyone could conjure up the will to perform such a grisly and heinous task.
Friday, January 5, 2018
Paul Popa and I did this song tonight for his 3 year old granddaughter Marley, whom I have met, and she is a sweet, beautiful girl. The song is I'd Do Anything, which is from the 1960 London West End musical, Oliver! And at the end, you'll hear Paul say a few words to Marley. This is about the love between a grandfather and granddaughter: a very special relationship.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tGL-LHVfIH4&feature=youtu.be
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tGL-LHVfIH4&feature=youtu.be
So, to get to the firing range, Oswald would have had to, somehow, get himself out to Irving to Ruth Paine's house, sneak into her garage and get the rifle which was wrapped in a blanket, assemble the rifle, somehow get himself to the Sports Drome Firing Range, which was back in Dallas, then when he was finished shooting, disassemble and clean the rifle and wrap it back up in the blanket, then get back out to Irving to sneak the rifle back into Ruth Paine's garage, and then, somehow, make his way back home to his boarding room in Dallas. Yeah, I can see that.
One could argue that I haven't proven that Oswald had no P.O. Box; that I have just made a case for it. But, I think it's stronger than that, and here's why:
Although I haven't provided direct proof that it's bogus, I have provided indirect proof. And that indirect proof is that the P.O. Box story includes things that are so implausible, that make no sense, that make the whole story implausible.
For instance, the idea that Oswald was subscribing to newspapers from Russia is implausible. The cost of mailing from Russia would have been prohibitive, especially for a guy who was making $1.11 an hour and had a family to support. Then, there is the simple fact that there are no Russian newspapers among Oswald's belongings. They should have found Russian newspapers in his boarding room, displaying a mailing label to him at that P.O. Box. They didn't.
I consider it implausible that police would not have asked Oswald about the P.O. Box on Saturday, since they found out about it in the wee hours of the morning on Saturday. Getting him to admit that he had that P.O. Box, to which the rifle was allegedly sent, would have been very incriminating. So, why wouldn't they go for that? But, the record shows that they claimed to wait until Sunday to ask him about the box, which means that they waited until after Oswald was dead to put any words in his mouth about it. And, being dead, Oswald couldn't refute the claim. How convenient.
Then, there is the claim that Oswald closed his box on May 14, 1963, which was 7 months and 5 days after he opened it, and which he supposedly did from New Orleans. Supposedly, he went into a New Orleans post office and closed his Dallas P.O. Box from New Orleans And that is impossible. Closing a post office box involves returning the key, so how could he do that from New Orleans? And what could they do with it? Mail it back to the Dallas? They weren't going to do that. They wouldn't do it today, and they wouldn't do it then.
Understand the rule, and the rule is that if there are lies within the story, then the whole story should be considered false. They wouldn't have to lie about anything if the story were true.
We have every right to assume that Oswald would behave rationally and practically- that is, in a practical manner- when it came to a P.O. Box. And remember that we have other, independent means to know that Oswald did not shoot Kennedy and did not order a rifle and have it sent anywhere. So, the argument that Oswald got the P.O. Box to hide his rifle-ordering can't be made. It's preposterous! If he was concerned about that, he would have walked into any gun shop, pawn shop, or even K-mart in Dallas and bought the same kind of rifle, or a better one, for cash. Who goes to the trouble of mail-ordering something that they can just pick up locally? And before you cite all the people who order on Amazon instead of buying locally, I'll point out that that doesn't involve acquiring a P.O. Box and getting a money order. It involves the convenience of shopping online, in a one-step process, where everything, including paying for it, is done with keyboard and mouse, on the spot.
Plus, in this case, Oswald ordering using an alias (supposedly) was useless. Since "A. Hidell's" rifle was supposedly sent to the P.O. Box of Lee Harvey Oswald, that linked it to Oswald. And since there was no A. Hidell, it left only Oswald as the recipient of the rifle. It would seem that Oswald went to a heck of a lot of trouble for nothing. All the running around he supposedly did on March 12 alone exceeded, by far, his just going into a gun shop or other outlet and buying a rifle. He probably passed places he could have bought a rifle on his way to the post office. He may have passed more than one.
And supposedly, Oswald did a lot of riding around on buses with that rifle. How did he get home from the downtown post office when he picked up the rifle? By bus? How did he get to New Orleans? Definitely by bus. Ruth Paine claimed to drive him to the bus station. So, he must have had the rifle with him, right? That is, according to the story.
I don't know if it was legal to bring a rifle onto a bus in 1963, but I can tell you this: I was riding buses in 1963, and I NEVER SAW ANYONE TOTING A RIFLE ON A BUS.
And realize that traveling to New Orleans did not involve a metro bus. It involved Greyhound, or some other private carrier. And they had the right to establish their own policy about passengers toting weapons. And, the policy Greyhound has today is that "no weapons of any kind" are allowed on their buses. Do you know if it was any different in 1963? And I realize that regardless, if it was a little revolver in his pocket, he could have gotten away with it. But, we are talking about an infantry rifle.
Imagine if you were on a bus, and some guy gets on, and he's toting an infantry rifle. Would that not stick out to you, as in: "Jesus Christ. What the fuck is that guy doing with a rifle, and I wonder if the God-damn thing is loaded?"
So, Ruth Paine, who hated guns, had to ride in a car with Oswald in which he had a rifle. And she saw him get on a bus with it to New Orleans. So, when she went down to New Orleans to get Marina, and they were packing her car, why didn't she ask herself, "I wonder if they are going to try to put Oswald's rifle in my car." Or, are we supposed to believe that this pacifist forgot all about it by then?
But, Oswald, supposedly, did a lot of riding around on buses with that rifle. How did he get to the firing range to practice? Remember? Where he supposedly shot diagonally at other people's targets? A real prince. Did Ruth Paine drive him there to? Because he had no car, and he had no friends. Have I mentioned that? No friends, no friends, no friends, no friends, no friends, no friends.
You see: the whole rifle story is bogus. So, what chance is there that the P.O. Box is real? What chance is there that the guy writing the bogus story would even know about the P.O. Box? Doesn't it seem far more likely that everything in the story is made up, including the P.O. Box?
The story goes that Oswald got the P.O. Box because he expected to be moving around a lot, and he didn't want to have to change his mailing address. But, according to the story, Oswald was constantly changing his P.O. Box: first getting one in downtown Dallas, then getting one in New Orleans, and then getting one at the Postal Annex Building in Dealey Plaza. What's so convenient about that? Wouldn't you get tired of it, the rigamoro? I'm tired just thinking about it. Have I mentioned that Dr. Cinque hates waiting on lines. I hate it with a passion.
And Oswald did all that just to get newspapers? We don't even have any evidence of the newspapers.
Although I haven't provided direct proof that it's bogus, I have provided indirect proof. And that indirect proof is that the P.O. Box story includes things that are so implausible, that make no sense, that make the whole story implausible.
For instance, the idea that Oswald was subscribing to newspapers from Russia is implausible. The cost of mailing from Russia would have been prohibitive, especially for a guy who was making $1.11 an hour and had a family to support. Then, there is the simple fact that there are no Russian newspapers among Oswald's belongings. They should have found Russian newspapers in his boarding room, displaying a mailing label to him at that P.O. Box. They didn't.
I consider it implausible that police would not have asked Oswald about the P.O. Box on Saturday, since they found out about it in the wee hours of the morning on Saturday. Getting him to admit that he had that P.O. Box, to which the rifle was allegedly sent, would have been very incriminating. So, why wouldn't they go for that? But, the record shows that they claimed to wait until Sunday to ask him about the box, which means that they waited until after Oswald was dead to put any words in his mouth about it. And, being dead, Oswald couldn't refute the claim. How convenient.
Then, there is the claim that Oswald closed his box on May 14, 1963, which was 7 months and 5 days after he opened it, and which he supposedly did from New Orleans. Supposedly, he went into a New Orleans post office and closed his Dallas P.O. Box from New Orleans And that is impossible. Closing a post office box involves returning the key, so how could he do that from New Orleans? And what could they do with it? Mail it back to the Dallas? They weren't going to do that. They wouldn't do it today, and they wouldn't do it then.
Understand the rule, and the rule is that if there are lies within the story, then the whole story should be considered false. They wouldn't have to lie about anything if the story were true.
We have every right to assume that Oswald would behave rationally and practically- that is, in a practical manner- when it came to a P.O. Box. And remember that we have other, independent means to know that Oswald did not shoot Kennedy and did not order a rifle and have it sent anywhere. So, the argument that Oswald got the P.O. Box to hide his rifle-ordering can't be made. It's preposterous! If he was concerned about that, he would have walked into any gun shop, pawn shop, or even K-mart in Dallas and bought the same kind of rifle, or a better one, for cash. Who goes to the trouble of mail-ordering something that they can just pick up locally? And before you cite all the people who order on Amazon instead of buying locally, I'll point out that that doesn't involve acquiring a P.O. Box and getting a money order. It involves the convenience of shopping online, in a one-step process, where everything, including paying for it, is done with keyboard and mouse, on the spot.
Plus, in this case, Oswald ordering using an alias (supposedly) was useless. Since "A. Hidell's" rifle was supposedly sent to the P.O. Box of Lee Harvey Oswald, that linked it to Oswald. And since there was no A. Hidell, it left only Oswald as the recipient of the rifle. It would seem that Oswald went to a heck of a lot of trouble for nothing. All the running around he supposedly did on March 12 alone exceeded, by far, his just going into a gun shop or other outlet and buying a rifle. He probably passed places he could have bought a rifle on his way to the post office. He may have passed more than one.
And supposedly, Oswald did a lot of riding around on buses with that rifle. How did he get home from the downtown post office when he picked up the rifle? By bus? How did he get to New Orleans? Definitely by bus. Ruth Paine claimed to drive him to the bus station. So, he must have had the rifle with him, right? That is, according to the story.
I don't know if it was legal to bring a rifle onto a bus in 1963, but I can tell you this: I was riding buses in 1963, and I NEVER SAW ANYONE TOTING A RIFLE ON A BUS.
And realize that traveling to New Orleans did not involve a metro bus. It involved Greyhound, or some other private carrier. And they had the right to establish their own policy about passengers toting weapons. And, the policy Greyhound has today is that "no weapons of any kind" are allowed on their buses. Do you know if it was any different in 1963? And I realize that regardless, if it was a little revolver in his pocket, he could have gotten away with it. But, we are talking about an infantry rifle.
Imagine if you were on a bus, and some guy gets on, and he's toting an infantry rifle. Would that not stick out to you, as in: "Jesus Christ. What the fuck is that guy doing with a rifle, and I wonder if the God-damn thing is loaded?"
So, Ruth Paine, who hated guns, had to ride in a car with Oswald in which he had a rifle. And she saw him get on a bus with it to New Orleans. So, when she went down to New Orleans to get Marina, and they were packing her car, why didn't she ask herself, "I wonder if they are going to try to put Oswald's rifle in my car." Or, are we supposed to believe that this pacifist forgot all about it by then?
But, Oswald, supposedly, did a lot of riding around on buses with that rifle. How did he get to the firing range to practice? Remember? Where he supposedly shot diagonally at other people's targets? A real prince. Did Ruth Paine drive him there to? Because he had no car, and he had no friends. Have I mentioned that? No friends, no friends, no friends, no friends, no friends, no friends.
You see: the whole rifle story is bogus. So, what chance is there that the P.O. Box is real? What chance is there that the guy writing the bogus story would even know about the P.O. Box? Doesn't it seem far more likely that everything in the story is made up, including the P.O. Box?
The story goes that Oswald got the P.O. Box because he expected to be moving around a lot, and he didn't want to have to change his mailing address. But, according to the story, Oswald was constantly changing his P.O. Box: first getting one in downtown Dallas, then getting one in New Orleans, and then getting one at the Postal Annex Building in Dealey Plaza. What's so convenient about that? Wouldn't you get tired of it, the rigamoro? I'm tired just thinking about it. Have I mentioned that Dr. Cinque hates waiting on lines. I hate it with a passion.
And Oswald did all that just to get newspapers? We don't even have any evidence of the newspapers.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)







