Monday, December 25, 2017

The actress Heather Mendez-Urich died late on Christmas Eve. She played Louisa in The Sound of Music in 1964. She was 68. 



She died of cancer, and the irony is that she was devoting her life to helping people who have cancer. When her husband, the actor Robert Urich, died of a rare form of cancer in 2002, she started the Robert Urich Foundation which raises money for cancer research and to help cancer patients. Her terminal brain cancer was diagnosed just 4 weeks before her death. 

I am one of the millions of people who think The Sound of Music is the greatest musical of all time. And I am quite sure it is the movie I have seen more times than any other, and I enjoy it every time. And last winter, there was a Broadway revival of The Sound of Music which came to Austin, and which I attended with my niece Jessica.  And it was magnificent. They did a fantastic job. The singing, the acting, and even the sets were superb.



And, in honor of Heather Mendez-Urich, I am going to watch The Sound of Music again this evening. I'm sure I'll enjoy it, but sadly. 



Sunday, December 24, 2017

Jack Ruby owned a white 1960 two-door sedan Oldsmobile. He did not own a pickup truck. He bought the car that very year, in January 1963, and he bought it from a private party, but he had to borrow the money from the bank to pay for it. His finances weren't great. He handled a lot of money. A lot of money went through his hands. But, he had a lot of debts and obligations, including past tax debt to the IRS. So, his finances weren't great, and he didn't own two vehicles.
Plus, he lived in an apartment, and he had no need for a truck. The Carousel Club was just a storefront he was renting. He didn't own it either.
So, why assume that Jack Ruby owned a pickup truck? Is it because of the Julia Mercer story? But, there is no reason to think that she saw the real Jack Ruby driving a pickup truck and delivering a rifle to Dealey Plaza at 11:30. There are numerous witnesses placing Ruby at the Dallas Morning News building from 11 o'clock onward, starting with Gladys Craddock, a low-level receptionist who greeted him at 11. It included Tony Zoppi, the Entertainment editor. It included Don Campbell, the advertising manager. It included Hugh Aynesworth, the reporter. And, there were more.
So, who did Julia Ann Mercer see? She may have seen a Jack Ruby double. We know that was happening. We know the Jack Ruby figure at the DPD at 2:00 was NOT Jack Ruby. Ruby said he wasn't there at the time, and he had no reason to lie about it. But, even stronger, is the fact that at 2:00 he was on the phone at the Carousel Club talking to his sister Irene in Chicago, and there are phone records to prove it. So, that guy wasn't Ruby, and maybe he is the one that Julia Ann Mercer saw.
Jack Ruby was NOT involved in the JFK assassination, and he did not know Lee Harvey Oswald. But, there does appear to have been, and continues to be, a concerted effort to disseminate vague and mysterious stories of Ruby being involved, which I maintain is just a "baiting the buffs". An example is the recent "watch the fireworks" story that the mainstream media reported matter-of-factly, without even suggesting any skepticism. It's just keeping people busy with distracting nonsense so that they don't go anywhere near the real truth, which is that Jack Ruby was innocent, that he did not shoot Oswald, that he was tricked into believing that he did because the Dallas Police, whom he admired and hero-worshipped, told him that he did. He was bamboozled, and so was the public. It's time to wake up.

Saturday, December 23, 2017

Look at this statement by Dr. Fred Beiberdorf:

"I was asked to remove myself from the basement parking area at--prior to Oswald's being moved, and was told by police officers at that time that only police personnel were being allowed in the area."

So, this confirms that, prior to Oswald being brought down, they evacuated the basement area. Why? So, they could have their confrontation with Jack Ruby and hustle him up to the 5th floor, that's why. 

And Beiberdorf gave us a time. He said that he crossed through the basement area at 9:45. So, he crossed through then, and then it was evacuated. This fits perfectly with my assumption that the fracas with Ruby occurred at 10 to 10:15.

And why did Dr. Beiberdorf claim that Detective Leavelle rode with him in the middle compartment of the ambulance? We know it isn't true. We can see Leavelle climbing into the rear through the tailgate. And, we can see him getting out the same way upon arrival at Parkland. So, why did the Beib say that? It's very baffling.

And read his testimony concerning Jack Ruby:

"At the 2:05 time that I saw him, he, as I stated in this document--Well, let me just go through what, as best I can recall, what was said. I identified myself to him. I don't recall that he said who he was or that either the police officer with him or the FBI agent with him at the time identified him to me. I told him that I had been asked to see if he had any complaints or injuries as a result of the earlier scuffle he had in the city hall."
"He assured me that he was not injured in any way. He took off his coat, which he had on at the time, and showed me a few bruises on the medial aspect of his right arm, and I also noted a few bruises on his right wrist which appeared to be fresh, but, he assured me these weren't bothering him, and he had no other injuries. He, at that time---oh, I don't recall the exact words he used, but he expressed an admiration for the police officers. And in saying that he had no injuries he stated that the police had just done what they had to do, that they hadn't injured him any more than necessary, than he would expect in such a scuffle, and again spoke of how the police were doing their job and how they were doing their job well."


That is weird. How could Ruby be concerned with praising the Dallas Police at a time like that, when he had just destroyed his entire life and lost everything? You would think that his focus would be on himself. It's like he was drunk or intoxicated. Are you aware of any other time in the history of criminal justice that a culprit did that? And what does it say about Leavelle's claim that, after shooting Oswald, Ruby tried to shoot him? Do you think there is any chance that Ruby would have shot any of his beloved Dallas Police? Jim Leavelle was, and is, a terrible liar. 

It just isn't normal for Ruby to be waxing on in praise of the Dallas Police at a time like that. And again, my mind goes to drugging: the mind-altering drug that he must have been given.

I am going to give you the link to Dr. Beiberdorf's testimony, and you'll notice that he said nothing to the Warren Commission about having performed artificial respiration on Oswald.

http://mcadams.posc.mu.edu/russ/testimony/bieberdo.htm

But now, let's turn to his FBI statement:




Note that this was written by an FBI agent, although who I don't know. It states that Dr. Beiberdorf could not detect a pulse, heartbeat, or breathing on Oswald. Hmm; that sounds like dead. 

It states that the Beib said that someone had pulled Oswald's shirt up exposing the puncture wound, but that no external bleeding was evident. In that case, how did all this blood get on the floor?



That's a long way for the blood to travel, and it would have had to leave a heck of a lot behind on his clothes. Yet, we don't see any, and Beiberdorf said the puncture wound was clean; bloodless. 

Then, it states that the Beib could feel the bullet between Oswald's ribs on his right side. So, he went looking for that, did he? That's surprising. I mean, all those doctors and nurses in Trauma Room One at Parkland didn't do that with Kennedy. Then, it says that the Beib may have missed Oswald's heartbeat because of all the noise in the jail office at the time. But, he checked Oswald for pulses. It says so. And that wouldn't be affected by the noise. And the pulse is more important anyway. What you want to know is whether the patient has circulation, and if you don't have a pulse, you don't have circulation, regardless of what the heart is doing. Then it says that the Beib commenced massaging the sternum. MASSAGING THE STERNUM? What the heck is he talking about? There's a thing called the sternal rub which is done to irritate the subject in order to determine if he is really unconscious. Cardiac resuscitation involves compressing the sternum in order to compress the heart to squeeze the blood out of it and into the arteries. It is not done with the expectation that it will restart the heart. It is done as a mechanical alternative to the heart beating. 

Beiberdorf was a doctor, and it says that he determined that Oswald was not breathing. So, wouldn't he perform cardio and pulmonary resuscitation both? Frankly, I have no idea what was meant by MASSAGING THE STERNUM. If he literally meant rubbing over the sternum, that would accomplish nothing, and a doctor would know that. And don't try to tell me that Beiberdorf was leaning over Oswald and performing chest compressions. I don't believe it. If that were true, we would have heard about it directly. We would have heard it described that way by observers. Furthermore, since it is NOT expected to restart the heart, you would keep it up all the way to the hospital. You wouldn't stop just because the ambulance attendants arrived. You would keep doing it with him on the stretcher. Why not? Here's an article about it:

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-cpr-stretcher/does-cpr-on-a-moving-stretcher-work-idUSTRE66T51N20100730

Secret Service Agent Forest Sorrels said that he saw someone performing "artificial respiration" on Oswald, and Beiberdorf never even claimed to do that. Did anyone else? 

Mr. SORRELS. I got down to the basement floor, and I headed right into the jailer's office. And at that time Oswald was laying on the floor and someone was giving him artificial respiration.
Mr. HUBERT. By mechanical means?
Mr. SORRELS. No; by hand. I recall seeing that his stomach was uncovered, his shirt was pulled up, and the man apparently was over him giving him artificial respiration by his hands.


That does not make sense. Mouth to mouth resuscitation was developed in 1956, and it was adopted by the U.S. Military in 1957. This was 1963. So, no one would have done artificial respiration by hand. It would have been mouth to mouth. How could a Secret  Service agent, one trained to deal with all kinds of Presidential emergencies, not know about this? He DEFINITELY did not see anyone provide artificial respiration by hand. And the only thing that would have been effective for cardiac resuscitation was chest compressions. And again: there is no chance that Beiberdorf did that. 

The bottom line is that the entire account of resuscitative efforts being applied to Oswald in the jail office is mired in confusion, uncertainty, and doubt. It seems HIGHLY LIKELY to me that it never happened.  I don't believe that ANY resuscitative work was done on Oswald in the jail office. 




  




Another thing that disgusts me is the way they patronized Ruby, with everybody immediately calling him by his first name. It was Jack this and Jack that. Did they do that with Charles Manson? How about Jeffrey Dahmer? 

I read the account of SS Agent Forest Sorrels, who, reportedly, was the first to question Ruby after the shooting, which occurred a few minutes after 11:21, therefore 11:24 or so. Of course, in reality, Ruby was swifted up to the 5th floor after his own incident with police in the garage which probably occurred in the 10:00 to 10:15 time frame, and somebody had to be talking to him long before 11:24. And note also that, like James Bookhout, Forrest Sorrels claimed to remain up on the 3rd floor during the jail transfer, except instead of claiming to remain in Fritz' office, Sorrels claimed to wait in the office of Deputy Police Chief Charles Batchelor. And then upon hearing that Oswald was shot, he went down to the jail office, where he said he saw someone administering "artificial respiration" to Oswald.  Artificial respiration by hand, he went on to say. I wonder what he meant. Was he really talking about cardiac resuscitation? There is a report that Bieberdorf "massaged Oswald's sternum" but when the heart stops, you compress the sternum. Did Bieberdorf do that? And he wouldn't do it unless the heart had stopped. So, the question is: DID LEE HARVEY OSWALD GO INTO CARDIAC ARREST IN THE JAIL OFFICE?  

But think about it: If Oswald went into cardiac arrest, then it would have taken very firm compressions to mechanically operate his heart to get it to circulate blood, and imagine the effect that would have on his bleeding. Yet, when Oswald was rolled out into the garage, we STILL don't see any sign of blood, and his color doesn't look all that bad either. 


Color-wise, what is the difference between Oswald and the others?


In the above image, Oswald' right hand looks huge and waxen and very pale, while his left hand looks normal in size and color. And how could Oswald' right arm wind up in that location? He couldn't place it there, right? He was unconscious, right? So, somebody else must have done it, right? But, what for? He was an abdominal gunshot victim, and you don't put anything over the abdomen. You see how artificial that looks, and most likely, it is an altered image. I don't know what that white is supposed to be, but we still aren't seeing any sign of blood, and you would expect blood to show up on white, right? Also, if Oswald required resuscitation in the garage, why didn't it continue? Why isn't it being done here? Usually, once you start it, you keep it going until you hand him off to the surgeon. 

Or, did someone check and see that his heart had started to beat spontaneously again? But wait: that isn't in any of the reports. THE WHOLE THING ABOUT OSWALD BEING RESUSCITATED IN THE JAIL OFFICE IS MIRED IN UNCERTAINTY AND DOUBT.

But, let's get back to Sorrels. He claimed to interview Jack Ruby shortly after the shooting, and he spoke of saying, Jack this and Jack that. Then, FBI Agent Ray Hall claimed to interview Ruby an hour later (after Sorrels was gone) and he said the same thing, that he told him Jack this and Jack that. Everybody was calling Ruby Jack. And my hunch is that not only were they calling him Jack, but they were calling him Jack in a very friendly manner, that they were kind to him. They weren't at all hostile or even adversarial. They were easy-going. They were gentle.  

And it's very strange because according to Jim Leavelle, the shooter tried to shoot again and pointed the gun at him, and that the only reason he, Leavelle, survived is because his partner L.C. Graves saved his life. If that's true, then why wasn't Ruby charged with trying to shoot a police officer as well? And most important: how, after Ruby shot Oswald and then tried to shoot Leavelle and then struggled with police in the garage for half a minute in a wild melee, could any of them address him deferentially as Jack? How do you go from one to the other?

Wouldn't the "our buddy Jack" routine dissolve after he tried to shoot a police officer? 

And of course, the whole "be kind to Jack" routine continued at the Dallas County Jail where Ruby had several full-time jailers whose job it was to not only take care of him but to entertain him, as in playing cards with him. And I mentioned that Sheriff Decker would visit Ruby once a week to make sure his accommodations were adequate. "You getting enough to eat, Jack? How is the food working out for you? Anything else I can get you?" They were way too patronizing of him, considering that he was supposed to be a murderer.

So, why the rough treatment of Oswald and the soft treatment of Ruby? Although I should point out that, it got softer with Oswald as time progressed. Watch this video from Saturday night. It's eerily casual and easy-going. You see Oswald going up to Bookhout in the hall and casually asking him, "What have you got against Broby?" Isn't that awfully casual?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=04aL80prg7U



As I said in the last post, it takes maturity and discipline to do this analysis. You need to be mature to recognize that there is often conflicting evidence. And there is also a hierarchy to the evidence. So, you can't hone-in on something that you like, such as that guy did in citing statements that Jack Ruby made which indicated that he shot Oswald, and consider it mission accomplished; be sure to turn out the lights. No, you have to look at the entire body of evidence. You have to determine what the preponderance of the evidence points to. And you have to know what trumps what. 

And you have to do all that without any bias. You can't start with the conclusion that you desire to be true and then work back from it to find evidence which you can cite to support it.  That is intellectually dishonest. And yet, people do it all the time.

So, how does it work in this case, to determine who the Garage Shooter of Lee Harvey Oswald was? Well, it starts with closely examining the images of the Garage Shooter and seeing if he is a good match to Jack Ruby. And that is at the top of the evidence hierarchy.  And not because I say so, but because objective reality says so. If the Garage Shooter was Jack Ruby, then his images should match those of Jack Ruby- extremely well. That is such a simple and obvious statement, it almost seems superfluous to say it. But, it needs to be said because there are so many people who seem to be oblivious to it. 

The reason comparing images is so important is because it is the closest we are ever going to get to seeing with our own eyes- and devoid of third party risk- who it was.  If the day ever comes (and it never will) that a time machine is invented by which we can go back and time and watch the event directly, that will beat looking at images. But, since that day is never going to come, looking at photographic and film images is the best we are ever going to do.

So, that is at the top of the hierarchy. What is at the bottom? Witness testimonies are at the bottom. Unfortunately, that is true. You have heard of the Innocence Project, which has gotten many wrongly condemned convicts freed by way of DNA evidence. But, how do you think they got convicted in the first place? Usually, it was by eye-witness testimonies- that were wrong. Dead wrong.

And worse yet are hearsay testimonies. Oh my God. I am reminded of the joke that you could have 10 people lined up in a row and have the first person tell a narrative to the second person. Then, he whispers it to the next person, and so on and so forth. And the joke is that the narrative that comes out of the mouth of the last person is woefully different from what the first person said.  There is a reason why hearsay cannot be admitted as evidence in a court of law. And that actually happened at the mock trial. Attorney Bill Simpich decided to go with the 1978 Carolyn Arnold story about seeing Oswald eating in the 2nd floor lunch room at 12:25, except it was just hearsay. Carolyn Arnold never testified to that effect. She was never sworn-in to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth. It was just a hearsay article in the newspaper. Yet, Simpich claimed it at trial, and it was not contested by the judge or the prosecutors. The mock trial made a mockery of trials. 

Witness statements are, by definition, subjective, and objective evidence is always to be preferred. 

But, there may be objective conclusions that can be drawn about testimonies. For instance, it is a fact that only Dallas Police claimed to recognize Ruby in the garage. No reporter or cameraman claimed to recognize Ruby- at the time.  Some later claimed to have recognized him, but that's not what I am talking about. What I am talking about is a reporter or cameraman citing the name Jack Ruby before it was told to them by Dallas Police. There is not a one who did that; not even Hugh Aynesworth who knew Jack Ruby well and spent time with him that weekend. Hugh claimed to see the shooter "zip on in" but he didn't know he was Jack Ruby until the police announced it.

And, that no one except certain Dallas Police claimed to recognize Ruby in the garage is an objective fact. And that Dallas Police removed the shooter from the garage without first handcuffing him is also an objective fact, and it is inexplicable and inexcusable in the conduct of police work. How come 3 detectives got the bright idea, simultaneously, to handcuff the shooter as soon as they got through the jail office door? If they could think of it on that side of the door, why couldn't they think of it on the other side of the door?
There is really no excuse for this, and it screams out loud that there is something terribly wrong with the story.

Then, there is the complete lack of any motive for Ruby to shoot Oswald. And remember that the official one was invented by Ruby's lawyer, and even though Ruby came to spout it himself some, the fact is that at the time, he had no reason for shooting Oswald and no awareness that he did. 

It's pretty widely accepted that Ruby shooting Oswald was a spur of the moment thing, an impulse. That is, except by the buffs. According to the buffs, Ruby shot Oswald because the Mafia ordered him to, and they threatened to hurt or kill his family if he didn't. And that is a ridiculous position to take. Would you? If the Mafia ordered you to kill somebody or else they were going to hurt or kill your family, would you do the killing. 

Let's look at it realistically. Other than in the Godfather and other Mafia movies, has that ever happened? Do you know of any instances in which someone committed a murder because the Mafia told him that if he didn't, then his loved ones would die? 

What would you do in that situation? And I realize that it's purely hypothetical because you are never going to be in that situation. But, I presume you would seek to protect your family by moving them, by hiring private detectives to guard them, by informing the police of the threat, by keeping them armed, by staying with them and keeping yourself armed and vigilant. But, though you love your family, you are not going to kill anybody. And nobody would, and that includes Jack Ruby. 

So really, that is just a stupid idea by people who have watched one too many Mafia movies. It's childish. It's fanciful. And it is completely steeped in drama and theater but not in real life.

And the same thing goes for all the stories of Jack Ruby being a violent man. There isn't a stitch of evidence to back these claims. And EVERYTHING we see of him in films and footage and photographs support that he was not the least bit violent. The fact is that Jack Ruby was a very devout Jew.  He spent two hours on Friday evening at the Synagogue talking to his rabbi. He took his religion very seriously. 

When you look at the strong, compelling photographic evidence that the Garage Shooter was NOT Ruby, at the strange behavior of police who obviously did not want the shooter to be seen, when you look at Ruby's behavior- who sends a $25 money order right before killing someone? The two acts were next to each other, but they don't fit. They don't segue.

The preponderance of evidence is overwhelming that Jack Ruby did not shoot Lee Harvey Oswald. And to cite statements by Ruby which suggest otherwise, as if those statements are a trump card that trumps everything else, is just plain wrong, woefully wrong. And it is extremely immature not to recognize how paltry it is. 


  



Friday, December 22, 2017

An adversary quoted this testimony of Jack Ruby's from his Warren Commission interrogation, which sounds like an admission of having shot Oswald. Note first that this interrogation took place after Ruby's trial, in which he got to see the films of the shooting repeatedly. And, as he watched the films, he saw what happened. And since he presumed it was himself, the vision of the movie became his own mental vision, like a memory. So, the fact that Ruby, at times, was able to give an account of shooting Oswald means nothing. And it means nothing because we know from comparing the images that the Garage Shooter was NOT him. It takes maturity and discipline to do this, and the images rule. When they tell you something, you don't dismiss it because of anybody's lip-flapping, not even Ruby's.

Mr. RUBY. I had the gun in my right hip pocket, and impulsively, if that is the correct word here, I saw him, and that is all I can say. And I didn't care what happened to me. I think I used the words, "You killed my President, you rat." The next thing, I was down on the floor. I said, "I am Jack Ruby. You all know me." I never used anything malicious, nothing like s.o.b. I never said that I wanted to get three more off, as they stated. The only words, and I was highly emotional; to Ray Hall--he interrogated more than any other person down there--all I believe I said to him was, "I didn't want Mrs. Kennedy to come back to trial."

But now, let's look at this account in comparison to what happened at the spectacle. So, Ruby said, in advance of shooting Oswald, "You killed my President, you rat." Oh really? Well imagine if the Garage Shooter had said it in advance. You tell me how Oswald, Graves, and Leavelle, as well as others, didn't turn and glance at the guy who said it. It is crystal clear from watching the films that the Garage Shooter just rushed in without saying anything. Therefore, if you take what Ruby claimed at face value, it is Prima Facie evidence that he was NOT the Garage Shooter. That's because the Garage Shooter definitely did not do that. The Garage Shooter was silent. That is very clear. There is not the slightest sight or sound of him vocalizing during or before the spectacle.

Then, Ruby said he was put down on the floor. But, the Garage Shooter was NEVER put down on the floor. At least not in the garage he wasn't. He remained on his feet the whole time. Instead, he was covered up and hustled out of there. But, he stayed on his feet; he was never put down on the floor. So, that is another disparity.

And even his account that he proclaimed that he was Jack Ruby and that they all knew him, there is no sign of the Garage Shooter saying that- or anything. The Garage Shooter was mute; silent; and that is crystal clear in all of the films. It's clear as a bell because we don't hear him talking, and we don't see him talking. You can tell when a person is talking, right? Well, he never talked. He didn't say a word. And that is Disparity #3.

I don't know what to make of him citing Ray Hall as the one who interrogated him the most. Ray Hall was an FBI agent. And he claimed to interview Jack Ruby, starting at 12:40 on Sunday afternoon. But, it was interrupted by various things.

But, the point is that Ruby's account does not mesh with what we see in the films. Just as the images don't match him, the action doesn't match what he claimed happened. And that points to the incident with Ruby occurring separately and before the televised Garage Spectacle.


OIC Chairman Larry Rivera has done an excellent program on the New JFK Show about Sylvia Duran and Oswald's supposed trip to Mexico City. I never realized until watching it the extent to which Sylvia Duran was pressured and abused to support the fiction that Oswald went to Mexico City. Poor woman.  

Larry pointed out that the ONLY evidence for Oswald having stayed at his supposed hotel in Mexico City is his name in the registry. That's it. No images. No witnesses. No tell-tale signs of him in the room. Nothing. 

And, they did a good job of discussing why the Mexico City ruse was ever conceived. Was it to blame the assassination on Castro? I think it's possible that the plotters were originally going to use the JFK assassination as a pretext to invade Cuba. But, that aspect got called off, and probably by LBJ. Was it, as Jim Fetzer suggested, to make it seem that Oswald was going to escape to Cuba after the assassination?  WC Attorney David Belin had it that Oswald was going to escape to Mexico after the assassination, but I have no idea what he based that on. Of course, the whole idea is ridiculous since Oswald didn't assassinate anybody. 

I consider this a very important part of the case. Once you realize that they framed Oswald for going to Mexico City, how could they not have framed him otherwise? And that Larry Rivera has joined the chorus about this is very heartening. 

And note that not only did Oswald deny going to Mexico City, but when first asked, his wife Marina denied it too. She didn't know a thing about it. Of course, over time, she came to parrot everything she was told. The mental subjugation of Marina Oswald is a unique case in the annals of mind control, as extreme as it gets. Oh, but for the monstrous wickedness of it all. 

But, watch this presentation by Larry Rivera because it is JFK assassination research at its finest. 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mNKrLr2X5og&t=1701s