Oswald in the doorway: the blog of the Oswald Innocence Campaign, by Ralph Cinque

I put Dr. McKnight's brilliant argument up about the failure of the FBI to treat Oswald the same as they did Lovelady the night of November 23, that is, show them both the blow-up of the Altgens doorway and ask them both who Doorman was. 

There have been two responses to that so far, and one of them by bpete. I'll post their responses first and then my response to them. 


bpete1969 

they did try to get to the bottom of things. Fritz asked Oswald where he 
was when the president came by...Oswald said he was in the building. 

OHLeeRedux

11:26 AM (1 hour ago)

Why didn't the FBI show Oswald and Frazier a "photo" of the infamous
Badgeman and ask them who it was?

Why didn't they run the Zapruder film for them and ask for their opinions
on why JFK goes "back and to the left, back and to the left" after being
shot in the head?

Why indeed were Mr. Frazier and Mr. Oswald not flown to Maryland to
observe the autopsy and offer their opinions on the forensic evidence?

You are right, Ralph. The FBI was certainly hiding something by excluding
two shipping clerks from participation in the most important criminal
investigation of the twentieth century. 

Ralph Cinque:

Fritz: Where were you at the time of the shots?
Oswald: I was out with Bill Shelley in front.
bpete: Fritz asked Oswald where he was when the president came by and Oswald said he was in the building.

Are you losing it completely, bpete?

And to Olly, are you for real? They didn't exclude one of the shipping clerks. They included one of the shipping clerks, Billy Lovelady. They showed up at Lovelady's house the night of November 23rd with a blow-up of the doorway that was 30"x 40". So, why didn't they do the same with Oswald? He was alive and well at the time. Why was the opinion of one of the shipping clerks relevant and the other shipping clerk not?

The reason to show Oswald the image of Doorman was because people, from all over the world, thought he was Oswald. So, you ask Oswald.

Why did they ask Lovelady?  Well whatever xxxxxxx reason you can think of for asking Lovelady, applied equally to Oswald in a rational universe.

There was one disputed figure and two possible contenders. They had both of them. They should have asked both of them. Period.

Both of you struck out, and Dr. McKnight is rounding the bases after hitting a home run.