Oswald in the doorway: the blog of the Oswald Innocence Campaign, by Ralph Cinque

Look at this Casey Quinlan slide again, and remember who he is: the public school teacher who gets accolades, awards, invitations, etc. 

Casey took liberties, big liberties. He put words in Oswald's mouth that he never said. He designated Black Hole Man as Bill Shelley, which I have never seen done before. Then he's got images below of Lovelady and Shelley, both of which are suspect. We'll start with Shelley. 

Is that the same guy? I don't know. It's not jumping out at me. If it is, then he's obviously older. So, why not use an image of Shelley from the time of the assassination? 

But, Quinlan's picture of Lovelady was definitely not Lovelady.

That image originally looked like this.

Notice how much stockier he originally was than what Quinlan showed.

But wait! Dirty rotten scoundrel! Look what Quinlan did! First, he changed the aspect ratio to slim Lovelady down. But second, he flipped it! He left-to-right flipped it! It's a mirror image! Look how the pack of cigarettes moved from the left pocket to the right! 

It's definitely the same image. You can see the filing cabinets and the clothes hanging behind him, although they're reversed too.

Which is the real one? The one on the right. And you can tell that just by looking at the whole frame.

Fritz' office was to the right. Remember? We've seen it a thousand times. So this is the proper configuration. Therefore the other one is fake; it was flipped.

So, Casey Quinlan used an altered, flipped image. That is blatantly dishonest. So, why is Casey Quinlan lying? Why is he deceiving? Here, he is supposed to be this award-winning teacher, a great communicator, an inspiring speaker, and he is nothing but a liar and a con man. 

But, it's worse than that. That man in the picture, whether in his normal proportions or artificially slimmed down, was not Billy Lovelady. Let's compare him unaltered to the real Lovelady. 

You know, there are so many contradictory pictures of Lovelady that it's hard to know which one to use. What I have done here is use the 1967 image of Lovelady by CBS. Is that the same guy? Look at their ears, their left ears. Those ears are definitely not the same. Different ears means different men. And how do the shirt sprawls look so different? On the left, it looks normal, which is to say, triangular. But, on the right, it's rectangular, which is impossible. Try on some shirts. I guarantee you can't get yours to do that. A box opening to a button-down shirt? Give me a break.

So, what it means is that Casey Quinlan used an altered, flipped image of a Lovelady imposter with an impossible shirt opening.

So, let's sum up: Casey is attributing something to Oswald that Oswald never remotely said. He's designating Bill Shelley to be Black Hole Man (so named because his face is like a black hole from outer space) as Bill Shelley even though that has never been ascertained, and where that man was actually the real Lovelady. He has used a questionable image of Shelley, and he has used an absolutely false image of Lovelady (impostor), where the image is also flipped and altered. And for that they give the guy awards?

Casey J. Quinlan was born and raised in Kansas City and has been a high school teacher for over 32 years in Kansas. Casey served in the United States Army with the 9th Infantry as a medical corpsman during the Vietnam War. Mr. Quinlan earned a Bachelor of Science in Education and a Master’s degree in American History from Emporia State University in Emporia, Kansas. He is the Director of Project JFK/CSI Dallas, a student-oriented historical experience for high school and college students.

Casey has been the featured speaker at many colleges throughout the Midwest, including the Alf Landon Lecture Series at Kansas State University; the William Allen White School of Journalism at the University of Kansas; and the Johnson County Community College in Overland Park, Kansas.

Mr. Quinlan served as a guest historian for the A&E Network and the History Channel for Oliver Stone’s movie, JFK. In 1995, Casey was named the Outstanding Educator of the Year by JFK Lancer. From 1997, Mr. Quinlan has served as an adjunct instructor at Friends University in Wichita, Kansas; Ottawa University in Overland Park, Kansas and Washburn University’s Criminal Justice Department in Topeka, Kansas. Today, Mr. Quinlan teaches American History at Basehor-Linwood High School in Bonner Springs, Kansas. He is the co-author of Beyond the Fenceline: The Ed Hoffman Story.