The Idiot Backes thinks lip-flapping can destroy. It takes more than that. You actually have to show something.
Now, if all that is shadow, then what is casting it? What is the object that is throwing off that shadow? If you don't know, then you can't claim that it's shadow. And show me any other photograph from the entire history of photography going back to 1820 in which a shadow got laid down like that, with a disc around the eye.