Oswald in the doorway: the blog of the Oswald Innocence Campaign, by Ralph Cinque

It is important to realize that at the Altgens photo reenactment, I placed the surrogate for Black Tie Man as close to me as he could possibly be. He was physically against me- we were in direct contact with no space in-between us- and you can't get any closer than that. But, you can see that I have an intact shoulder. There is a horizontal span there between my head and the point of my shoulder.  On Doorman, it is just a weird diagonal slash with no horizontal span at all; none. And no, he was not dropping his shoulder down on that side. He would have had to have been deformed and paralyzed to assume such a position. You can see part of his right shoulder on our left, and his left shoulder was in the same plane as his right shoulder. So, you can just extend that line across to see where his left shoulder should have been. 

That may seem to you like he's leaning a little, but he's not. What he is doing is rotating a little- to his right. But, his shoulder should definitely be extending out into the area of Black Tie Man's white shirt. There should be a horizontal span there, and there isn't. His left shoulder is missing. It was cut off when they plopped Black Tie Man into the picture. It also resulted in gouging out his face and deforming his ear on his left side, which you can plainly see. 

That is NOT a legitimate image. It is an altered image. It is physically, anatomically, and photographically impossible. And anyone who thinks otherwise needs to provide another picture like this one from the entire spectrum of photography going back to 1820. I say that no other such picture exists, and I defy anyone to come up with one.