I found an image that looks similar to Lovelady in the right eye.
But, notice on the right how squeezed and crinkled the skin is to get such a tight squint. But, Lovelady's face doesn't look tightened at all. He actually looks quite relaxed. He doesn't have any crow's feet or lines under his eye. So, how could he be squinting like that without drawing up the skin? In other words, you have to pinch the eye to get it to squint like that, but Lovelady isn't pinching. The other guy is pinching, but not Lovelady. So, Lovelady's eyes in this image are a fabrication, and there is no doubt about it.